| Home team | Batter | Away team | Batter(s) | Ground | Season |
| Surrey | JB Hobbs | Hampshire | JA Newman | The Oval | 1927 |
| Gloucestershire | BH Lyon | Essex | J O’Connor | Bristol | 1930 |
| Middlesex | HJ Enthoven | Sussex | KS Duleepsinhji | Lord’s | 1930 |
| Australia | AR Morris | England | DCS Compton | Adelaide | 1946/47 |
| Maharashtra | MR Rege | Bombay | UM Merchant and DG Phadkar | Poona | 1948/49 |
| Yorkshire | L Hutton | MCC | PBH May | Scarborough | 1952 |
| Kent | MC Cowdrey | Essex | DJ Insole | Gillingham | 1955 |
| Queensland | GS Chappell | Victoria | AJ Sieler | Brisbane | 1973/74 |
| Worcestershire | JA Ormrod | Somerset | BC Rose | Worcester | 1980 |
| New Zealand | AH Jones | Sri Lanka | AP Gurusinha | Hamilton | 1990/91 |
| Glamorgan | HL Morris | Nottinghamshire | RT Robinson | Swansea | 1993 |
| South Australia | PC Nobes | Queensland | ML Hayden | Adelaide | 1993/94 |
| Hampshire | ML Hayden | Warwickshire | DL Hemp | Southampton | 1997 |
| Essex | SG Law | Yorkshire | MP Vaughan | Chelmsford | 1999 |
| Western Australia | MJ North | Victoria | CJL Rogers | Perth | 2008/09 |
| Zimbabwe XI | T Taibu | Afghanistan | Noor Ali Zadran | Mutare | 2009/10 |
| South Zone | KD Karthik | West Zone | YK Pathan | Hyderabad | 2009/10 |
| Australia | DA Warner | India | V Kohli | Adelaide | 2014/15 |
| Nottinghamshire | JM Clarke | Warwickshire | DP Sibley | Nottingham | 2019 |
| Auckland | MS Chapman | Northern Districts | JF Carter | Auckland | 2019/20 |
| Auckland | WT O’Donnell | Wellington | MG Bracewell | Auckland | 2020/21 |
| Lancashire | KK Jennings | Durham | DG Bedingham | Blackpool | 2024 |
Thanks to Keith Walmsley, Andrew Samson, Mark Spooner, David Griffin, Stephen Blades
Last updated 24 May 2024