| 1963 | Clay Cross and Danesmoor Second XI |
| 1964 | Farnsfield |
| 1965 | Hasland |
| 1966 | Kiveton S.W.W. |
| 1967 | Clipstone Second XI |
| Waleswood | |
| 1968 | Shirebrook Second XI |
| Tuxford | |
| 1969 | Blyth |
| 1970 | Clay Cross Works Second XI |
| 1971 | Sheepbridge Works |
| 1972 | Sherwood Colliery |
| 1973-1989 | No competition |
| 1990 | Everton |
| 1991 | Rockware Glass |
| 1992 | Everton |
| 1993 | Marshalls |
| 1994 | Babworth Road (Retford) |
| 1995 | Pilsley |
| 1996 | Waleswood |
| 1997 | Manton |
Thanks to Pete Griffiths