| Year | Winners | Runners Up |
| 1922 | London Road Church | Murrayfield |
| 1923 | Murrayfield | Rosedale |
| 1924 | Rosedale | Portsburgh |
| 1925 | London Road Church | St Martins |
| 1926 | Edinburgh Indians | Central Wesleyan |
| 1927 | Edinburgh Indians | Meadowbank |
| 1928 | Edinburgh Indians | Meadowbank |
| 1929 | Portsburgh | St Katherine’s |
| 1930 | St Luke’s | King’s Park |
| 1931 | Portsburgh | Meadowbank |
| 1932 | Melrosian | Edinburgh West Indians |
| 1933 | Melville | Portsburgh |
| 1934 | Melville | London Road Church |
| 1935 | not completed | |
| 1936 | Western | Melville |
| 1937 | Portsburgh | London Road Church |
| 1938 | St Luke’s | Portsburgh |
| 1939 | St Luke’s | Colinton |
| 1940-1954 | no competition | |
| 1955 | Corstorphine | London Road |
| 1956 | London Road & Nomads | (Shared) |
| 1957 | London Road | Meadowbank |
| 1958 | Carrick Knowe | Meadowbank |
| 1959 | Carrick Knowe | Newington |
| 1960 | Newington | Carrick Knowe |
| 1961 | London Road | Newington |
| 1962 | London Road | Elldee |
| 1963 | London Road | Brunswick ‘A’ |
| 1964 | London Road | Reid Memorial Church |
| 1965 | London Road | St Thomas’s |
| 1966 | London Road | Sighthill |
| 1967 | London Road | Royal Botanic Gardens |
| 1968 | Sighthill | Corstorphine |
| 1969 | London Road | Elldee |
| 1970 | London Road | Corstorphine |
| 1971 | Elldee | London Road |
| 1972 | Elldee | Maccabi |
| 1973 | Elldee | City Hospital |
| 1974 | Elldee | Royal Bank of Scotland |
| 1975 | Royal Bank of Scotland | London Road |
| 1976 | Corstorphine | Royal Bank of Scotland |
| 1977 | Corstorphine | Royal Bank of Scotland |
| 1978 | Bank of Scotland | Mitre |
| 1979 | Bank of Scotland | Royal Bank of Scotland |
| 1980 | Royal Bank of Scotland | Bank of Scotland |
| 1981 | Mitre | Royal Bank of Scotland |
| 1982 | Corstorphine | Mitre |
| 1983 | Corstorphine | Mitre |
| 1984 | Hall Advertising | Maccabi |
| 1985 | London Road | Life Association |
| 1986 | Holy Cross | Corstorphine |
| 1987 | London Road | Mitre |
| 1988 | Corstorphine | Holy Cross |
| 1989 | Corstorphine | London Road |
| 1990 | Holy Cross | Marchmont |
| 1991 | Corstorphine | Marchmont |
| 1992 | Corstorphine | Marchmont |
| 1993 | Marchmont | unknown |
| 1994 | Marchmont | Edinburgh District Council |
| 1995 | Standard Life | Marchmont |
| 1996 | Murrayfield | Holy Cross |
| 1997 | Marchmont | Murrayfield |
| 1998 | Standard Life | Corstorphine |
| 1999 | Standard Life | Marchmont |
| 2000 | Muslim | Cramond |
| 2001 | Muslim | Maccabi |
| 2002 | Edinburgh | Holy Cross |
| 2003 | Marchmont | Edinburgh |
| 2004 | Murrayfield DAFS | Maccabi |
| 2005 | Edinburgh | Cramond |
| 2006 | Edinburgh | Musselburgh |
| 2007 | Standard Life | Edinburgh |
| 2008 | Edinburgh | Leith Franklin Academical Beige |
| 2009 | Edinburgh | Murrayfield DAFS |
| 2010 | Standard Life | Leith Franklin Academical Beige |
| 2011 | Holy Cross | Murrayfield DAFS |
| 2012 | Murrayfield DAFS | Leith Franklin Academical Beige |
| 2013 | Murrayfield DAFS | Morton |
| 2014 | Holy Cross | Marchmont |
| 2015 | Murrayfield DAFS | Holy Cross |
| 2016 | Drummond Trinity | Morton |
| 2017 | Murrayfield DAFS | Musselburgh |
| 2018 | Morton | Murrayfield DAFS |
| 2019 | Drummond Trinity | Holy Cross |
| 2020 | no competition | |
| 2021 | Morton | Drummond Trinity |
| 2022 | Edinburgh South | Kirk Brae |
| 2023 | Morton | Livingston |
| 2024 | Morton | Edinburgh South |
| 2025 | Marchmont | Murrayfield DAFS |
Thanks to Alan Veitch, Neil Leitch