| 1984 | Scunthorpe Third XI |
| 1985 | Caistor Second XI |
| 1986 | Kirton Lindsey |
| 1987 | Broughton Second XI |
| 1988 | Findus |
| 1989 | Keelby |
| 1990 | Bottesford Town |
| 1991 | North Thoresby |
| 1992 | Littlefields |
| 1993 | Club C.C. |
| 1994 | Holton-le-Clay |
| 1995 | Belton Second XI |
| 1996 | TSB College |
| 1997 | Hainton |
| 1998 | Holton-le-Clay Second XI |
Brett Smith