| 1949 | Burringham |
| 1950 | Broughton |
| 1951 | Beltoft |
| 1952 | Alkborough |
| 1953 | Ashby Corinthians |
| 1954 | unknown |
| 1955 | unknown |
| 1956 | Nuform Sports Second XI |
| 1957 | Messingham Second XI |
| 1958 | Scotter Second XI |
| 1959 | Alkborough Second XI |
| 1960 | North Melting Shop |
| 1961 | Central Engineering Workshops |
| 1962 | Alkborough Second XI |
| 1963 | Ashby Corinthians |
| 1964 | Scotter Second XI |
| 1965 | Hibaldstow |
| 1966 | Epworth Town |
Brett Smith, Neil Simpson