| W Yalden (23 & 14, 2nd inns) | Surrey v Hampshire | Hambledon | 1776 |
| Earl Winterton (8 & 0, 2nd inns) | MCC v Cambridge Town | Lord’s | 1840 |
| J Boning (21 & 16, 2nd inns) | Cambridge Town v MCC | Lord’s | 1840 |
| F Noyes (31 & 8, 5 & 9) | Nottinghamshire v Hampshire | Southampton (Antelope) | 1843 |
In all cases, the player was allowed to bat twice because another player was absent. Only Noyes batted twice in both innings.
Thanks to Pelham Barton and Kevin Jones
Last updated 17 May 2023